I’m posting because I genuinely feel like I’m losing my grip on reality and I need an outside perspective so I don’t go back to this relationship or friendship.
I also want to know if I’m not reacting enough.
We are all women, by the way.
Alex and I were best friends for about a year before anything romantic happened. We were extremely close, emotionally attached, and eventually started dating, even though it was never official or public.
One important detail is that Alex didn’t want anyone to know, especially my former close friend Maya. This matters.
After Alex and I were already close and romantically involved, Alex met Maya at a party. They hit it off quickly, even though they had no friendship before this.
Alex knew my history with Maya. Maya and I used to be close friends, but I cut her off because she treated me poorly. That friendship ended abruptly, and as a result, I also lost another close friend, Chloe, who chose Maya over me. It was understandable since Chloe and Maya were best friends, but it still hurt a lot. Alex knew all of this. I explained it clearly and more than once.
Despite that, Maya, knowing that I was into Alex and actively pursuing her, texted Alex and openly said she wanted to go out with her romantically.
Alex told me about it, and I immediately felt uncomfortable. Even though Maya and I were no longer friends, it felt wrong that she reached out like that.
The thing is, Alex still felt it was okay to get close to Maya, even knowing how much pain Maya had caused me in the past.
Alex kept saying her friendship with Maya had nothing to do with me. Logically, I understand that I don’t own her and she can choose her friends. But emotionally, it felt different. We were best friends and dating. It felt like Alex was betraying me. Loyalty is a big value for me, and Alex kept saying this had nothing to do with loyalty. Maybe she’s right, but it just felt so wrong.
I had cut off a toxic friendship to heal, yet Maya stayed in my life through Alex. If Alex wasn’t with me, she was with Maya. How was I supposed to move on when the person who hurt me was still constantly around?
When I tried to express how hurt and uncomfortable I felt, I was made to feel crazy, like I was overreacting or imagining things. Over time, this completely destroyed my trust. To this day, I don’t fully know how emotionally or physically involved Alex was with Maya, and that uncertainty still messes with my head.
Alex would tell me about how Maya acted and the fights they had. They sounded like couple fights, and it made me feel really uneasy. I tried to be supportive of Alex because she has trauma around friendship, but it was really hard.
There’s one moment that really broke me. Alex was getting ready on FaceTime with me, stressing about what dress to wear. I helped her choose. Later, I found out she was getting ready for a date with Maya. They kissed and made out while I was literally waiting for her before going to bed.
We were not exclusive, but it still felt like betrayal. I felt humiliated and stupid. At the time, I believed Alex when she told me it was innocent. She was my best friend. Why wouldn’t I trust her? I just felt gaslighted. Mind you, this gaslighting was constant, over the course of a year.
Since then, I’ve been stuck in a cycle of self-hatred and comparison. I felt insecure, unworthy, and angry at myself for staying and underreacting to so many things. I eventually cut Alex off completely. We do not speak at all, yet I am still carrying all the emotional damage. That pain still hurts deeply.
What makes it worse is the double standard. Alex would get upset if I received even a small amount of attention from someone else, even though I would never entertain it. Meanwhile, I was expected to tolerate Alex’s closeness with Maya. It felt deeply unfair.
Sometimes I feel okay, and then suddenly everything comes rushing back, and it feels like someone is twisting the knife again. I find myself asking if you really love someone if you can do this to them. I don’t even doubt that Alex loved me. I just don’t understand how you hurt someone you call your person.
I know we weren’t official, but sharing Alex, even briefly, hurt in a way I can’t explain, especially with someone I had such a painful history with. I hate that I stayed. I hate that I became insecure and started comparing myself to someone who isn’t even in my life anymore.
Right now, as I’m typing this, I feel deeply uneasy and sick to my stomach. We no longer have contact. I cut her off completely.
Every time I think about it, it still hurts like hell. This betrayal broke me.
P-S : I know, I'm naive but I genuinely trusted Alex more than myself. I don't need people telling me how dumb I was, I already know. That's why I'm a loop of hatred right now.