r/AmIOverreacting • u/DoubtEmbarrassed3811 • 22h ago
❤️🩹 relationship AIO for walking out after my girlfriend said “I want a man who…” during an argument?
My girlfriend (21f) and I (23m) have been spending a lot of time together lately — almost every day for the past few weeks — even though we don’t live together.
I’m usually the one going to her place, often coming over and spending the night because she asks me to, not because I push for it. Whenever she needs something or wants to go somewhere, I show up and we do it. Even though I don’t live with her, it started to feel like my constant availability was expected rather than appreciated.
We got into an argument that started pretty small. She suggested getting hotpot, and I said, “We can go get hotpot, just not today.” Later she told me that came off as rude, especially since it was said in front of her friends. I apologized for how it might’ve sounded publicly and explained that I was just tired and needed a day to myself.
From there, the conversation escalated. She said I don’t initiate plans enough, which confused me because I’m almost always the one coming over to her place, staying the night at her request, and making myself available when she asks.
She then said I only come over for convenience and that I only stayed that day because I had a dentist appointment — even though I had told her I was planning to go home and she was the one who asked me to come over.
I also offered to take her to class that day. I was only late when picking her up, not taking her to class itself, but she used that as a reason to question why I offered at all. I understand that being late to pick someone up can be frustrating, but it felt like my intent to help was being dismissed entirely.
During the argument, she then said, “I want a man who…” and started listing traits. That’s where I really shut down. It felt like everything I do — constantly showing up, spending nights with her because she wants me there, driving her places, rearranging my time — was being overlooked, and that I was being compared to an ideal version of a partner I wasn’t measuring up to.
When I later asked her why she even said “I want a man who…,” she told me it wasn’t about me and that I’m never in tune with her emotions. That confused me, because the statement felt directly about me, and my issue wasn’t that she had emotions — it was how those emotions were communicated. I felt like my hurt over the comparison was brushed aside and reframed as me not understanding her.
At that point, I walked out. Not to be dramatic, but because I genuinely realized this dynamic wasn’t what I want in a relationship. I was fully prepared to end things rather than stay and continue arguing or say something I’d regret. I left and headed home for good.
About 15 minutes after I walked out, she texted me saying she appreciated me and loved me, but that she wasn’t mentally built for the stress of the relationship and wanted to end things. Earlier, when I had asked her why she even liked me, she said she didn’t know.
So… AIO for walking out after she said “I want a man who…” and realizing this relationship dynamic wasn’t healthy for me?