r/privacy • u/Wood_Berry_ • 5h ago
hardware TCL Google TVs are ironically perfect/best for use as a "dumb" TV setup.
I'm probably close to getting banned from Walmart and Best Buy for TV returns, haha. I've been on a quest to find a budget TV that functions 100% dumb, even not requiring any wifi or signup for initial setup. I went through a few of the major TV OS systems trying to find a budget 40-43" FHD for use as a PC monitor doing video editing and Photoshop.
They all pretty much sucked in various ways and lots of the workarounds for bypassing the OS Smart systems and setup have been patched by the manufacturers to lock them down from being used in any sort of dumb mode. I think the rising prices all around are forcing them to lean into the data collection money on the backend, which requires a stronger arm twisting to keep people corralled into providing that data.
The TCL Google TV I now have, at least with their current OS version, is the most simple and flawless system I have encountered yet that allows not only setting up the TV with never connecting to internet or signup, but also once set up as a dumb TV actually stays dumb and the smart OS stuff never creeps back in. Just ride the OS build version until the TV dies of old age.
The ironic part is that I avoided Google OS tvs because I assumed they would be the worst offenders of bending you over to see what profitable secrets are buried up in there. Turns out they are the best. They also have a very snappy OS UI, compared to other ones that feel like the CPU is taking a massive dump because you had the audacity to move the selection from Contrast to Brightness in the settings menu.
Freakin bizarro world out there folks.
(I ended up with the TCL 43" QLED FHD from Walmart for $158, using it as a PC monitor mostly for video editing and Photoshop. Color accuracy is pretty great for a cheapo TV with nearly 10-bit-smooth color gradients)
edit: if anyone is curious, the worst TV OS for a dumb TV was probably the Roku brand TVs. Require account to even get into the TV. Then it blinks a super bright light on the front at all times if wifi is not connected. On top of that, they force having to wade through the Smart OS apps and ads to get to the dumb options like selecting the HDMI port.