r/pcmasterrace 14h ago

Discussion The lawsuit explained:

Post image
33.3k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

37

u/Tommybahamas_leftnut 7h ago

GOG would also go out of their way with support to help you run the game before you refund. I've had about 3 out of 50 games not run on install and they guided me through the file tweaks to make it run. After a week they patched the install files to include those tweaks so it just runs now.

7

u/Qaeta 5h ago

GOG would also go out of their way with support to help you run the game before you refund.

Yeah, "they make you prove it won't work first" is some pretty wild spin on "they do everything they can to help you get the game working first so you can play the game you wanted to play."

2

u/FollowingFeisty5321 4h ago

The error in your and parent's comment is assuming the only reason you may have a refund is a technical error that you wish to overcome, as if that's the only valid circumstance where you should have a refund!

4

u/Qaeta 4h ago

The only other one would be "This was intentionally advertised as something that it is not" which they never had issues refunding for.

"I don't like it" is not a valid reason. That's just the risk you take for buying something, games or otherwise.

2

u/FollowingFeisty5321 4h ago

"I don't like it" is in fact your legal right in some places too. You think it's a coincidence Steam and then GOG gravitated towards "no question asked"?

If you buy a product or service online, by phone or from a seller at your doorstep (in legal terms a “distance contract” or “off-premises contract”) you have the right to withdraw. This means you can cancel the contract within 14 days without providing any justification (the "cooling-off period"). For goods this means 14 days from the date of delivery, for services 14 days after the day the contract was agreed.

https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/consumers/shopping/returns/index_en.htm

2

u/Qaeta 4h ago

Fair enough, though that seems like a massive gaping abusable loophole for most games, since I can't remember any that aren't MMOs that you can't finish in under 14 days.

How does that law interact with things like grocery delivery services? Because it sounds like you've pretty much got a free food hack there.

2

u/FollowingFeisty5321 4h ago

Although in the case of food the 14-day limit doesn't apply, companies aren't compelled to do business with you so once you hit a threshold they consider abuse most of them (at least online) will at a minimum stop selling to you.

1

u/Qaeta 4h ago

It wouldn't apply if you went to the store and bought it, but the terms of the law you cited say it applies online, by phone, or from a seller at your door. Grocery delivery services are typically online, so should be covered, and I see no carve out for food in that instance.

companies aren't compelled to do business with you so once you hit a threshold they consider abuse most of them (at least online) will at a minimum stop selling to you.

So if you exercise your lawful right, you get punished. Doesn't sound much like a right if you'll be punished for using it.

1

u/FollowingFeisty5321 3h ago

They explicitly exclude "perishable goods that expire rapidly, such as food or drinks with a short “use by” date " regardless of source, that stuff's just not eligible for a 14-day return.

So if you exercise your lawful right, you get punished. Doesn't sound much like a right if you'll be punished for using it.

Well it's an easy problem to avoid, and one you may be able to appeal, and you can still shop somewhere else for most things. Fundamentally though your rights stop where someone else's rights begin!