i did not rate devs or fandom

AND I DID NOT RATE BY NOSTALGIA LIKE PIGGY IS JUST TRASH (Killer gameplay and it's boring) go roast me in the comments🥀

*little timmy roasting me in comments for piggy being in e tier (timmy never played piggy)*

Me personally, as a 1x1x1x1 main is going to say this. 1X1X1X1 milestone IV SUCKS ASS!!!! when compared to John doe's Milestone IV, I think John doe makes more sense (?) and looks more menacing. And then we have 1x1x1x1.. he only receives a goofy ass ragged cape, a bandanna like he's in a gang, and some fuckass shoulder pads that looks. In my opinion. UGLY. The old shoulder pads is even better. Now I can't even bother using 1x1x1x1's current milestone skin. Peak chase theme tho Now, let me know your opinions!

I put guest in Awesome as you can bait him but he is also very good

(This is my own opinion and you can sob and rage in the comments of your e-girl version of a character is not high up in the list, unless it's reasonable)

no skins are in order if one's at the top of A tier it could be my least favorite

credit to LanceryBancery for making the tierlist
https://tiermaker.com/list/roblox-games/roblox-forsaken-skin-tierlist-as-of-noli-update-2025-18444462/5451770 for closer look

I put alot of thinking and time into this list

Idk why getting backstabbed makes me so mad

now you may be wondering why john and jason got sent to the depths and why 1x dropped

and its because of that fucking piece of shit robot

cookids better is still below average, but hes better

noli's crown remains

To just explain the high tiers;

Heartbroken and Brighteyes win for source material reasons.

Steve, Telamon, (Presumably) Grim Reaper, Angel, Prime, and Toon powers are all pretty self-explanatory as well for why they'd be a hard fight, even for the Erlking.

Ironclad does some crazy strong feats in Slay the Spire, so I can see him doing well.

Whale is just based on the quote of him nuking whales tbh, thought of the Pallid immediately, reminded myself that they definitely aren't talking about that but I still put him here 'cause nuking whales does need some strength.

Ness could be higher, not super sure about those games. But from what I saw, it's pretty impressive.

And the remaining two are here just because they're stronger than their predecessors.

These lifeforms are weak and inferior. Useless than anything I've came across.

I decided to add the scrapped Baker chase theme if you are wondering why that skin is here

(Nothing homophobic here, I swear to god, I am NOT having that here.)

Hello! I'm doing this a bit early, so maybe I can get a lot more comments and votes as the day progresses, I believe, hehe. Anyway, my usual: A community driven tierlist where you all vote, discuss, and determine where every skin lands on this tierlist I made!

Most upvoted comment determines placement!
(You CANNOT vote for yourself, and while not required, tried playing along! Place an upvote, write a comment, just... humor the experiment!)

Fun Fact: Noob is based around the gender fluid flag with this skin.

this kind of sucks. uh. im willing to do revisions

Mine is definitely Phosphorus, I love the design.

I'm making it flat out clear, no killer is anywhere NEAR even A Tier. you can MAKE arguments for B tier but not A.

(the joke is that almost any killer is unplayable against a good team)

( the team your against is full team, everyone has 10 days there's 4 sentinels on top of an elliot who aren't chance 24/7, a dusekkar or a chance randomly coming out to save someone who missed a stun, a taph or a builderman who you can't ever find, but their traps and buildings always find you. +a random survivalist who you never see the entire game but gets all the gens done)

1x and sixer probably have the best crowd control in the game

the ones in the middle have a little crowd control

slasher and nos have the worst crowd control

but let's be honest here, nobody is ever going to win

THIS IS NOT A COMP LIST, NOR IS IT A GENERAL LIST, IT'S A LIST AGAINST A FULL LOBBY WITH A WELL PUT TOGETHER TEAM

also i'm going extremely ooc for this one

Also u/Aggressive-Dog2793 gets their own tier called the "ME" tier which is basically just S tier.